Today I am reviewing The Daughter by Jane Shemilt for TLC Book Tours. As always, I am provided with a copy of the book in exchange for my honest review.
About the book (from the publisher): Jenny is a successful family doctor, the mother of three great teenagers, married to a successful neurosurgeon.
But when her youngest child, fifteen year old Naomi, doesn’t come home after her school play, Jenny’s seemingly ideal life begins to crumble. The authorities launch a nationwide search with no success. Naomi has vanished, and her family is broken.
As the months pass, the worst-case scenarios – kidnapping, murder – seem less plausible. The trail has gone cold. Yet, for a desperate Jenny, the search has barely begun. More than a year after her daughter’s disappearance, she’s still digging for answers – and what she finds disturbs her. Everyone she’s trusted, everyone she’s thought she knew, has been keeping secrets, especially Naomi. Piecing together the traces her daughter left behind, Jenny discovers a very different Naomi from the girl she thought she’d raised.
Jenny knows she will never be able to find Naomi unless she discovers the whole truth about her daughter, a twisting, painful journey into the past that will lead to an almost unthinkable revelation.
My review: Secrets. They are the theme running throughout this beautifully written novel. The secrets we all hold; some relatively harmless, others much more dark in their import. Jenny, the protagonist, seems to successfully juggle the demands of her career with the demands of raising three teenagers. When her adored daughter disappears, nothing is the same as it was and the truths that are uncovered are shattering. She discovers that everyone – her husband, her twin sons, her daughter – has been keeping certain aspects of their lives secret.
What happens when those secrets are uncovered? How does one’s world change? How do we cope with the fact that we didn’t know our loved ones as well as we thought we did? How could we not know? The world tilts on its axis and we are forever changed.
Shemilt is a very fine writer. I found the story riveting. Told from Jenny’s point-of-view, it is lyrical and brutally honest at the same time. At the beginning of the book, Shemilt holds an onion out to us, beautiful and whole and seemingly complete. As the story progresses, the onion’s layers are systematically uncovered, each layer a secret that has to be peeled away in order to reveal another painful truth. The author skillfully takes us along for the ride, as Jenny searches for her daughter and faces the reality that the world she knew was merely the outermost layer of the onion.
This is also the story of the love a mother has for her children and of her commitment to them, a commitment that is sometimes resented by those she would protect, sometimes misguided, but always fierce in its single-minded devotion. Anyone who has ever loved and lost, or has learned that a loved one is not the person they appeared to be, will identify with Jenny’s struggle. I’ve been there. I know how it feels and I’ve asked the same questions of myself. How did I not know, how can this person I’ve known since the day he/she was born be so completely different than I thought? Was it all a lie?
It’s a mystery, a love story, and a cautionary tale. You will love this book.
About the author: While working full-time as a physician, Jane Shemilt received a M.A. in creative writing. She was shortlisted for the Janklow and Nesbit award and the Lucy Cavendish Fiction Prize for The Daughter, her first novel. She and her husband, a professor of neurosurgery, have five children and live in Bristol, England.
Good news! One of you will be the lucky winner of a copy of The Daughter. Just leave a comment here on this post, and I will pick a winner on Monday. Good luck! U.S. readers only.
Happy Thursday.
Sue says
Thank you for the great book review. Your analogy of the onion is brilliant. As a constant reader, it gives me great joy to read another reader’s analysis.
Jacki says
Ooooh, Claudia, this sounds like a good one. Fingers crossed that I will win it!
Janet says
This does sound like a fabulous read! and such a beautifully written review!
Melina says
Sounds very interesting. I’m always looking for new authors, so I’d love to win this one.
Vera says
This sounds great Claudia! Thanks for the chance…fingers crossed my name is picked.
Kim says
I know too well when those you have known for oh so long are not what you thought. I’d love to read this! Thanks Claudia!
Jo says
Being a mother of 5, this sounds interesting. Secrets among families is intriguing. Upon the death of my mother, we found out about a huge secret that had been kept for generations. This sounds
like a good read.
Regula says
I must read it. :-)
Regula
Mary says
Hi Claudia – back for a short time before heading to England so have had little reading time unfortunately. I did pick up very interesting book in Hungary though about the Gypsies around the world who are of course a culture unto themselves – very, very interesting! Problem now is I’m asleep in my pillows after a few pages – just can’t stay awake for long!
This book you have reviewed sounds interesting.
Hope life is good up north – I’m sure Spring is beautiful by now.
Hugs – Mary
Linda @ A La Carte says
Claudia, this sounds like my kind of book. I will add it to my list to read for sure! Your review is right on target as always.
Linda
Deanna Motsenbocker says
Please, please pick me! This book sounds amazing! I need something new to escape from my boring reality.
Deanna
jo(e) says
Oh, you’ve piqued my interest. I’m going to have to read it.
Charlotte says
Another one to add to the reading list.
Kathy says
Sounds like a great book.
Joan says
O, this sounds like my kind of read. Intrigue , medicine, relationships,……..thanks for sharing about this.
Your blog is fairly new to me and I find myself looking forward to what you have to share.
Chris K in Wisconsin says
This one sounds amazing! Great review. I have added it to my TBR list!!
melissa farley says
Another good on to add to my growing “must read” list. Thanks for another interesting review.
Susan says
Excellent review Claudia. You left me wanting to know more.
Big Texas Hugs,
Susan and Bentley
carol harrison says
This sounds very interesting. I love books where the layers are peeled back. Pick me, please.
Annie G says
Your review has my interest peaked, so I may have to get this book. You have a great way of reviewing the book in an interesting way that doesn’t give too much information!
Margy Coomer says
I’d love to read this book! If I win I can take it on vacation and indulge!
SandiC says
Oh my, my reading list grows every day. You’ve given me many authors to try, and I haven’t been disappointed. This book sounds intriguing; I must read it.
Myra says
Oooh, I would love to win this book!
I want to ask you something, though, too. We have been watching old reruns of Frasier ( we love it). Did Don ever do any of the Frasier episodes? I just knew it was him the other night. His hair was dark! In the episode, Fraser had rented an office next to Niles and was going to start seeing some patients. He was observing a group therapy session in Niles’ office, and Don was one of the patients. The brothers started arguing so much that the group got up and left. Tell me if I’m crazy and imagined that it was Don!! Myra
Claudia says
You’re not crazy! It was Don.
Linda Kimura says
I would love to read this book.
Thanks
Linda
Kellianne says
I enjoy this genre so! If I don’t win, it is going in my TBR pile for sure. Thanks for the review and contest.
Lorinda H. says
I would love to read this book! You have introduced me to so many wonderful books. I am currently reading the Louise Penny books (am on the fourth one in the series). Thank you for taking the time to do these reviews.
Lorinda
Barb H says
Sounds like the perfect summer read!
Nancy Blue Moon says
Sounds like this one is a “can’t put it down” book..I’ll be reading it whether I win or not….
pam in illinois says
Sounds like a great read! I have added it to my Amazon wish list. Thanks, Claudia
Sue says
This sounds like a good summer read!
JanL says
interesting review. hope I win, but if not, I’ve got another book for my library list.
Shari says
I’m looking for a great summer read. This one sounds intriguing. Thanks for reviewing Claudia!
Shirley Elliott says
Have not heard of this author or book but the book sounds wonderful. Would love to read it. Thanks for the opportunity to enter the giveaway! (shirparks@gmail.com)
Lee says
I just picked up a novel by Elizabeth Haynes on your recommendation~looking forward to a good escape!
This one sounds good, too! So many books to read-so little time!
Paula says
Your review makes me want to read it. If not here, I will order from my library. Have a great day.
Debbie in Oregon says
Wow, you’ve definitely peaked my interest in this book! Here’s my entry … pick me, pick me! :)
Claudia E says
This does sound like another good book!
Denise says
Your review really has me interested in this book.!
Michle Machala says
Just told my self that I need to read some this summer. Would love to start with this book! Thanks Claudia!
Phyllis says
This sounds like an intelligent read-thanks for the review.
Cindy says
I would love to read this book!
Stacy says
Sounds like a good read. I would love to win a copy.
Stacy L.
Fran Bricken says
Hi! I’m new to your site. A friend told me about your blog and I love it! I’m am an avid reader and I’m always in search for another good book. I have “The Daughter” on my wish list but after your review I’m “hot” to read it now. I love all things British, good mysteries and dysfunctional family stories, This book sounds like a perfect fit for me. Hope I win it!
Sylvia says
Oh, this sounds like a good one, Claudia!
Cheryl says
I’ll be buying this one for sure if you don’t pick me! It sounds quite good!
Nancy in PA says
Another great review, Claudia. I would love to read this book. Thank you for the opportunity.
Kim says
I’m looking for good summer reads, I will have to add this to my list!
Jane Price says
Pick me! Pick me! Pick me! This sounds like a real winner
jane-in-tx
Donna in Atlanta says
Another one to add to my insanely long list! Thanks for the chance!
Nancy says
Sounds like a book I would love to read.