Mockingbird Hill Cottage

Mockingbird Hill Cottage

  • About MHC
    • Disclosure
  • Dollhouses/Minis
    • Hummingbird Cottage
    • The Studio (Formerly TSP)
    • Dove Cottage
    • The Lake House
    • The Folk Art Dollhouse
    • The Modern Dollhouse
    • Dollhouse Source List, Information and Tutorials
  • On the Road
  • Collecting
    • Roseville Pottery
    • McCoy Pottery
    • Egg Cups
    • Bakelite
  • Press
  • Privacy Policy
You are here: Home / defending the small house / McMansions and the Small House

McMansions and the Small House

November 14, 2011 at 9:26 am by Claudia

my house – 1200 square feet

Good morning! Another Monday has rolled around. How do the weeks fly by so quickly? Time really does seem to go by more quickly these days. I’m not sure I have a lot to show for it, but there you go.

I’m so excited about the new series that Brenda and I are starting, “Defending the Small House.” My neighborhood consists of quirky, individual houses, many of them quite modest, along with some McMansions. The quirky and small have the edge, thank goodness. There was a building boom around here a few years ago. As more and more New Yorkers either sought a refuge away from the city or could no longer afford to live in the city, the population in our neck of the woods increased. There are a few newer McMansion communities that are unfinished. No one can afford these houses. Construction has halted.

We have 3 of these newer homes across the road from us. One of them, which is huge, is only used on the occasional weekend. While I am impressed by the money this young couple must have, I can’t help thinking what a waste that is. Really? You need all that space for the weekend? Hard to believe.

I grew up in a very small house. It was part of a suburban community of bungalows that sprang up after World War II. The houses all looked alike. I was young and school filled my days but I still knew that every house looked like the one next door. I longed for something different.

Nevertheless, my parents managed to raise 4 children in our tiny bungalow. That’s not to say we wouldn’t have loved more space. But none of us grew up traumatized from living in a small house. And I loved our modest, middle class community, which now, after 60 years or so of existence, looks old, established and has beautiful tree-lined streets.

Brenda’s House – 1010 square feet

Many of us are downsizing for a variety of reasons; empty nests, the economy, a too-high mortgage. And in the end, do we really need all that space? How many trees are chopped down so that the land around these new houses can be flat, boring and clear of any natural beauty? How many animals have lost their natural habitat and are displaced because everyone has to have a bigger home?

There is a movement happening. Much has been written about the small house. Sarah Susanka has been a strong advocate for the small house and its smaller footprint. For an even tinier footprint, visit Tumbleweed Tiny House Company.

I’ve really never had a choice as to the size of my home. Modest income = modest house. I’d love a wee bit more space for a laundry room and a downstairs bedroom. It may never happen. And we’ll be just fine. We have learned to live in a small space that leaves a small imprint on the land. Along the way, I’ve learned a lot about living comfortably in a small space.

Our house is small and charming and unlike any other house I’ve seen. It’s cozy.

That does it for me.

Our series starts tomorrow. Please join us!

Filed Under: defending the small house, Mockingbird Hill Cottage 31 Comments

Comments

  1. Zuzu says

    November 14, 2011 at 11:46 am

    Looking forward to it!
    ~ Zuzu

    Reply
  2. An Urban Cottage says

    November 14, 2011 at 12:11 pm

    Many of the cottages in my neighborhood are 700-900 square feet and they’re really charming. Most are four rooms: eat-in kitchen, living room and two bedrooms. Some of my neighbors see my 1200 as quite extravagant. They seem fine for a couple but in census records, we can see that families sometmies with several children made them their homes. Our “need” for space surely has changed.

    I have the Susanka books and they’re wonderful. I think they’re more for someone building a house rather than adapting or renovating but she’s got some great ideas.

    Reply
  3. poppilinnstudios says

    November 14, 2011 at 12:22 pm

    Claudia, I agree totally! I love a small home with personality. I think this country is in trouble because so many reached too far on credit! If you can’t pay for it, you can’t have it. I look forward to your new series.
    -Lynn

    Reply
  4. Char5 says

    November 14, 2011 at 12:30 pm

    I LOVE smaller homes! I grew up in one of those post WWII houses and my mom still lives there! My Cozy Home was built somewhere around 1930 and we believe that it was a Sears home (The Vallonia). It is aprox 2200 square feet total and has all the room we will ever need and plenty of charm. We are buying it from the owner who used to be our landlord, we love he and his daughters like family! I really enjoyed your post and I stand with you and Brenda on the position for smaller homes. Looking forward to your series!

    Reply
  5. BEACH BUNGALOW says

    November 14, 2011 at 12:35 pm

    Claudia, my laundry room is in the basement and I`d love to convert a closet upstairs into a setup like yours! With only 2 other closets in the house, however, this would leave very little storage for clothing, etc. Be happy with your little closet laundry; I love it!

    S
    xo

    Reply
  6. Vera @ Cozy Little Cabin says

    November 14, 2011 at 1:02 pm

    Count me in! I’m in a 80-100 year old house that is tiny! But I love it w/all its charm and quirkiness. I’ll be enjoying yours and Brenda’s series. . . . .

    Reply
  7. Terri says

    November 14, 2011 at 1:07 pm

    Oh how the time flies! I can hardly take in that it is November!
    I think you have a lovely home, and it is full of love and creativity. That makes it a very special home indeed!
    Hugs,
    Terri

    Reply
  8. pilgrimscottage says

    November 14, 2011 at 1:13 pm

    Claudia, I am so with you on this. Less is definitely more when it comes to living in a small home. I love small homes. Your home is so pretty and the porch is gorgeous! Brenda’s sweet cottage is just that…sweet!

    Reply
  9. Karen says

    November 14, 2011 at 1:17 pm

    I’m all for the smaller individual houses/cottages/bungalows/farmhouses… the McMansions of today have no personality.

    Reply
  10. bunny says

    November 14, 2011 at 1:23 pm

    I thought the McMansions were a California thing? It’s discouraging that it’s spread all through the country. My in laws have one right next door and needless to say, their privacy has flown the coop as the neighbors window looks out to their yard…It’s a shame and like you said..some of these people run out of money and then it just sits there like a memorial to greed.

    bunny

    Reply
  11. Cozy Little House says

    November 14, 2011 at 1:27 pm

    Yes, my little blue house looks so modest and ordinary. But I love it!
    Tried to call you earlier. Immediately went to voice mail…
    Brenda

    Reply
  12. Sharon says

    November 14, 2011 at 1:39 pm

    I’m looking forward to your series , my home is smallish by most standards , just under 2000 sq. ft. A small ranch that my husband and I built with the help of my dad in 1998. We added as much charm as we could afford at the time which wasn’t a lot, but I keep working on that.

    Reply
  13. Chy says

    November 14, 2011 at 1:49 pm

    I grew up in small houses when my parents were young and as their careers grew, our houses kept getting bigger and bigger. We went from cozy to stark white and cold. My husband and I made the choice early on to have a large family but knew it would mean a small house if I was to be a momma at home. Somehow, it worked to raise 6 in a house that is just over 1800 square feet. Our kids always had space but were close by. Now we have just one at home and suddenly it seems too big. We are building in the country and really struggling with staying with the same size, downsizing or building a bit bigger to accomodate soon-to-be spouses of our kids and grandbabies. I think we’ll end up somewhere in the middle.

    Watched a show this morning “My First Sale” and was quite taken back by the young family who had a beautiful 1500 square foot Colonial on a private lane in the trees. They HAD to sell because they were bringing home their first baby in a few months. And selling meant building a much bigger home and losing all the equity in the first house, borrowing more to buy the second one and having to come to the closing table with $7500 they didn’t have.

    And that made sense because??

    Shook my head. They should have stayed where they were and built up the equity. But I’m sure it’s just a sign of the times that even young families believe little babies need big houses. Sad.

    I’m off to tidy my cozy cottage! Looking forward to your new series.

    Chy

    Reply
  14. Connie says

    November 14, 2011 at 1:55 pm

    While I’m not an advocate of the small house, I am an advocate of building more than you actually need. Oh, sweetpea, why do those people build houses that are 10,000 or 50,000 s.f.? It just doesn’t make sense to me. Our old house was almost 5,000 s.f. and we didn’t live in 1/2 of it. This house is 1,800 s.f. and we do live in it…all of it. It’s not a McMansion or a “wee” house but it satisfies our needs.

    A friend built a HUGE gorgeous home, and they could afford to, but they’re in their 70s. I wanted to ask them WHY, but it would sound obnoxious or envious so I didn’t. Plus they travel—a LOT, so it just doesn’t make sense to me. Even with 5 boys and their families, I believe that’s what hotels are for when kids come to visit! I doubt I’d ever do that…build a huge house, I mean.

    Home is what you make it and ours is definitely a quiet, serene and well loved HOME.

    xoxo,
    Connie

    Reply
  15. The Garden Bell says

    November 14, 2011 at 2:22 pm

    This looks like fun. As I sit here and type away and bop around blogland. I’m listening to the hammering out back. Yes, we have another tear down going on behind us. They have removed all the trees again and probably no longer going to be a blade of grass on the land. My poor gardening friend is right in the middle now between two McMansions. So so sad to look out and see this. At least she still has the best garden around and we can still trade plants, as we bow our head in the dirt and not dare to look up at the ugliness of the mansions. The weird thing is they get done and have not a penny left for a single stick of furniture, a curtain on the many windows or a plant in the ground. Not my cup of tea. Enough ramblin’, I could go on and on, but save some for the new series.

    Reply
  16. Olive Cooper says

    November 14, 2011 at 2:36 pm

    So looking forward to this. I love our smaller home so much better because it is cozy and easier to keep clean. We do still have the other large tumble down old home. Joe stays there when he works and that is much cheaper than a hotel.

    Reply
  17. Echoes From the Hill says

    November 14, 2011 at 4:03 pm

    Your house might be small, but it has a large look. It has a LOT of charm. Love the porch!
    nancyr

    Reply
  18. Caseymini says

    November 14, 2011 at 5:09 pm

    Actually Claudia, my exact words were, “defending the small home”.LOL Either way, I think that the new series will be interesting! I will be looking forward to it.

    Reply
  19. Annie says

    November 14, 2011 at 5:09 pm

    Am I the only UK reader interested in this I wonder. My cousin in Arizona, who was born and raised here, says American houses are mostly way bigger than here, and rooms are roomier, as land is cheaper. Is that true?
    Our little house is just 1100 square feet spread over 3 floors, and although it’s a small house plenty of houses here are smaller. But we are still somehow found wanting by some people because we don’t live in a mansion.
    I am totally behind defending this style of living.

    Reply
  20. The Boston Lady says

    November 14, 2011 at 5:10 pm

    I will be there in my 1400 square footer! Ann

    Reply
  21. Norma says

    November 14, 2011 at 5:21 pm

    McMansions litter the housing developments down here too and like you I can’t understand their appeal.

    And looking at this pic of your house I’m just thinking what a cute dollhouse it would make …

    Reply
  22. Joanne says

    November 14, 2011 at 5:21 pm

    I love Tumbleweed homes ! In fact I posted about them once. I would love to see one in person. I live in a small cape and I love my home….though I would have loved a bit more room in our bedroom!
    Blessings, Joanne

    P.S. McMansions…YUCK!!!

    Reply
  23. Createology says

    November 14, 2011 at 9:19 pm

    Your home is very sweet and I look forward to your newest venue. Happy Small Spaces…

    Reply
  24. Lena says

    November 14, 2011 at 10:35 pm

    This will be an interesting series of posts to read. Diversity always makes life more interesting, I think.

    Best wishes,

    Lena
    xo

    Reply
  25. ImSoVintage says

    November 15, 2011 at 1:44 am

    I adore small houses. Looking forward to the series.
    Laura

    Reply
  26. Betty Jo says

    November 15, 2011 at 7:19 am

    This comment has been removed by the author.

    Reply
  27. Betty Jo says

    November 15, 2011 at 7:30 am

    I’ve been receiving info from Tumbleweed’s homes for years and so love them. Looking forward to the defending the small house posts by you and Brenda. As mentioned above, I’ll have to call it “defending the small home” as I don’t have a house.

    Reply
  28. Lucille says

    November 15, 2011 at 10:55 pm

    Personally, I think smaller is cozier as long as it’s not so small that it feels cramped. As long as there is room for everything. For instance, Claudia, you might not have a laundry room but you do have a large enough closet to house your appliances. You’re so lucky. My apartment is around 800 square feet. There is a smaller model available in the building but I would not want it because I’ve gotten rid of enough stuff as it is. There’s a limit to downsizing, after all. I could use an extra bedroom but I’m not willing to pay the extra $250 a month they would charge me. I would rather have that money in my pockets. So, I do without the space and I manage. No craft room but I deal with it. I just bring my stuff out and put it away when I’m finished.

    Reply
  29. Mary says

    November 16, 2011 at 12:01 pm

    Well here I am back at my small house (1400 sq.ft.) and loving it all over again after being away at the bottom of the world for over 3 weeks! Cozy cottages are the best as we know – the MacMansions around us are gorgeous but I would never want one.

    I rec’d your note dear about Reality Thurs. and understand. I just got in last night so am crazy busy – especially as I leave again very soon – more on that later.

    Love and hugs – will try to catch up with your missed posts soon – Internet was spotty and so costly on the ship.

    Reply
  30. Dogmom Diva says

    November 20, 2011 at 3:14 am

    Claudia, I love the series on smaller homes, our current home of 2.5 years is 1399 square feet..three bedrooms, two full baths..it’s actually laid out quite well, we just moved from 2500 sq feet to this, and that brings along all kinds of trouble. too much stuff, which we are working on getting donated..we are senior citizens so we are slower than most..but small is ok, less to heat and cool!

    Barb

    Reply
  31. Jennifer @ Town and Country Living says

    November 20, 2011 at 12:59 pm

    Claudia, your house reminds me a lot of my own. From the exterior to the layout of rooms inside. My house is somewhere around 1500 square feet and was built circa 1875. I love all the rooms in your house – your style is very similar to mine. Once I figure out how to use my camera properly, I’ll start posting photos of it on my blog (I’m new to the blogworld). I look forward to learning from you!

    Reply
Please check back to follow the conversation!

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Email
  • Instagram

Welcome!

Welcome!

I live in a little cottage in the country with my husband. It's a sweet place, sheltered by old trees and surrounded by gardens. The inside is full of the things we love. I love to write, I love my camera, I love creating, I love gardening. My decorating style is eclectic; full of vintage and a bit of whimsy.

I've worked in the theater for more years than I can count. I'm currently a voice, speech, dialect and text coach freelancing on Broadway, off Broadway, and in regional theater.

Thanks for stopping by.

Searching?

The Dogs

The Dogs

Scout & Riley. Riley left us in 2012. Scout left us in February 2016. Dearest babies. Dearest friends.

Winston - Our first dog. We miss you, sweetheart.

Lambs Like to Party

Lambs Like to Party

A Note

Thanks for visiting! Feel free to browse, read and enjoy. All content is my own; including photos and text. Please do not use anything on this site without permission.

Disclosure/Privacy Policy can be found in the Navigation Bar under ‘About MHC.’

Also, I love receiving comments! I do, however, reserve the right to delete any comment that is in poor taste, offensive or is verging on spam. It’s my blog. If you’re a bot or a troll you’ll be blocked. Thanks!

Archives

All Content © 2008 - 2025 Mockingbird Hill Cottage · Log in